COMEDYNERD

SNL vs SNL UK: Danny Dyer won the night Shane Gillis lost

Both shows aired on October 10. In London, Danny Dyer hosted one of SNL UK's best episodes yet. In New York, Shane Gillis called women at the gym whores, and a sketch about sneaking up on women made it worse.

On Saturday, October 10, both versions of Saturday Night Live went out on the same night. SNL UK came back from a week off with Danny Dyer hosting and Sasha Keable on music. A few hours later in New York, Shane Gillis hosted the American show for the third time, with Rosalía as musical guest.

We've argued SNL UK is catching up with the original. On October 10 it didn't need to catch up. It was simply the better show.

SNL UK: Danny Dyer, national treasure

Dyer's monologue was a lesson in how a host should use their reputation. He played up the Cockney hard man and explained that producers had banned exactly one swear word, the best one, naturally. He claimed he could do accents from all four corners of the UK, then gave up on Welsh the moment he tried it. He revealed that Who Do You Think You Are? had told him he's related to royalty. Then he closed on something unexpectedly sincere, telling the audience not to let their algorithms get the better of them. It was warm, self-aware and funny, which is harder than it looks.

He was everywhere after that, including a sketch about an ageing boyband and another as an odd character with a taste for drinking paint. Weekend Update took on the Conservative party conference, the show ran about seven minutes over, and nobody seemed to mind. Online, viewers were calling Dyer the best host SNL UK has had, and the episode possibly its best so far. It's hard to argue.

SNL: Shane Gillis, round three

Gillis has never looked comfortable in an SNL monologue, and this was his roughest yet. After a bit about being a fat guy at a New York gym, he turned to what women wear there: "I didn't know women just dress like whores now?" He went on about tight shorts and women filming themselves, called his sisters "two big, fat bitch sisters", and wrapped up with a riff about his haircut that landed on "You're either gay or you're Hitler."

The SNL house band, usually the most reliable laugh in the building, sat stone-faced. Variety's headline was Shane Gillis Bombs 'SNL' Monologue (Again).

The reaction since has been loud:

  • Dan Levy posted a video saying women in short shorts at the gym aren't whores, but the men calling them that are misogynists, and that more men need to say so.
  • Phoebe Robinson posted a video asking what, exactly, the joke was.
  • Jessica Valenti, the author, pointed out that Gillis knew the country is in the middle of a major conversation about sexual assault, and told the joke anyway.
  • Caro Claire Burke, author of Yesteryear, posted a response called "Thoughts from a whore," arguing the point of the joke wasn't to be funny but to remind women who's on top. It passed 200,000 views within a day.
  • Brenna Perez, a film producer, argued that calling workout clothes "dressing like a whore" is the first step toward "she was asking for it."
  • Under the clip on SNL's own Instagram, commenters asked who approved the joke at all, and pointed out that it aired during a week when a sexual assault case is dominating the conversation in the US.

Gillis had defenders too. But NBC has booked him three times, and it knows his act. A monologue goes through dress rehearsal like everything else on the show. Nobody at SNL can claim to be surprised by what went out.

The sneakers sketch

If the monologue were the only problem, you could put it down to one comic misjudging one room. Then came "Sneakers."

It's a documentary-style historical reenactment set in a 1920 boardroom in Lowell, Massachusetts, where the canvas shoe is being pitched. James Austin Johnson presents the invention; Gillis plays the man who wants to call them sneakers, because in these shoes a man can creep up on women without being heard. NBC's own write-up sells it with "Your wife will never hear you!"

Exclaim called it "unsavoury but not unfunny." We'd go further. A sketch whose whole engine is a man delighted that women won't hear him coming has a rapey vibe in any week. In the same episode as the "whores" monologue, and in this week of all weeks, it played like a show that hadn't noticed what it was saying. There's a sharp sketch to be written about men and what they find funny about women. This wasn't it, because the joke was never on the man.

Weekend Update: the British desk wins again

The cleanest comparison of the night is the one segment both shows share, and it went to London again.

Ania Magliano and Paddy Young took on the Conservative party conference, with Update writer Ed Night making an appearance at the desk. It had the bite and the sense of risk that made us call the British Update the better one in our cast guide: two stand-ups who still look like they're getting away with something.

In New York, Colin Jost and Michael Che worked through Trump's meltdown over missing out on the Nobel Peace Prize, Mike Johnson and a run of world leaders as Real Housewives. It was solid and very familiar. Tellingly, the best thing in the American Update wasn't the desk at all. It was Ashley Padilla as a mother whose babysitter cancelled and new cast member Grace Reiter as her impossible daughter, Coco, a character piece that stole the segment.

What the American show got right

It wasn't all bad in New York, and it's worth being fair:

  • "Upfront Heating & Air Conditioning", a pre-taped ad for a brutally honest HVAC company, is Gillis at his best: a guy playing a guy.
  • "Saying Goodbye" had Gillis as a man whose mother is dying in hospice, mainly worried it'll clash with his Jelly Roll tickets at the Sphere. Ben Marshall's Jelly Roll turned up as a spirit, with Teddy Swims and Rosalía joining in. It was strange and funny.
  • Grace Reiter had a big night all round, from Update to the closing chess tournament sketch.
  • Rosalía was, again, one of the best musical guests the show books.

The low points beyond the monologue: a cop talk show sketch that went nowhere, a cold open with Colin Jost's Pete Hegseth that nobody will remember, and Gillis dropping an f-bomb live during "Green Eggs & Ham," which he later apologized for.

The verdict

Same format, same night, opposite directions. SNL UK picked a host who knows exactly how the public sees him and turned that into 75 minutes of goodwill. SNL picked a host it knew would punch down, gave him the stage, then wrote him a sketch that punched down again.

SNL UK: one of its best nights yet, a host we'd book again tomorrow, and the stronger Weekend Update.

SNL: a few good sketches buried under a monologue and a sneakers bit that should never have made it to air.

October 10 goes to London.